
Is there a gender bias in literature? I don’t know, although there is some pretty damning evidence that something is amiss.
Tawni O’Dell wrote an essay on her experience with this subject, and her argument that there is a gender bias is convincing:
It wasn’t until many years later, … that I would feel the sting of gender bias in an area of my life where I least expected it: the publication of my first novel.
“Back Roads” was set in the coal-mining area where I grew up and was a dark, gritty portrayal of a family in crisis told entirely in the male first-person voice of 19-year-old Harley Altmyer. My publishing house was over the moon about the book, proclaiming me brilliant and tossing around phrases like “formidable talent” and “pitch-perfect prose.” The book was so good, as a matter of fact, that they thought it would be best to conceal the fact that it had been written by a woman.
I was informed over the phone one morning that Tawni was a “biker chick name” and no one would take the novel seriously if we used it.
I was stunned, not only because I had naively thought art was one area where sexism didn’t exist but because standing in my coffee-stained bathrobe in my suburban Chicago kitchen handing out juice boxes to my kids, I could hardly imagine anyone mistaking me for a biker chick.
My editor went on to inform me that they had decided to publish the book using my initials. That way they wouldn’t actually be lying and claiming I was a man but since the book was written in the male first person, everyone would assume it had been written by a man. Pretty sneaky.
Oh, it gets worse. Wait until you get to the part where she goes to a photo shoot and they ask her to get naked and pretend she is a wood nymph.
“… I heard a few gasps as I crunched barefoot through the snow, wrapped in yards of sparkling gauze, with my butt hanging out, and wondering to myself, Did John Irving ever have to do this?”
I bet not.
Read the essay here.